Hi there! I'm not sure that this is the right place, so if not, would the Toddlers and Preschoolers forum be more appropriate?
We have a little guy who will be 4 years old at the end of June. He stays home with my DH during the day and is with me and the girls in the evening. Because he didn't have many social opportunities, we enrolled him in 3 year old preschool and back in November, they had identified a speech delay (he was about a year behind in speech when we started) and a cognitive developmental delay (i.e., he has trouble remembering multi-step directions). He goes to preschool Tuesday and Thursday from 9:00 - 11:30 and since identifying the speech delay, they have him in a Speech Booster class on Mondays from 9:00 - 11:30.
We have his annual review meeting next week. We got a call a month ago from his case manager for us to give thought to holding our little guy back and have him repeat 3 year old preschool next year.
His case manager (that is with him in class on Tuesdays and Thursdays) felt that the 4 year old preschool curriculum was very academic and she didn't think he would be able to keep up. She also indicated that he gets very frustrated when people don't understand him. While he has progressed leaps and bounds since they started him in the speech booster class, I think that it may not be enough to get him ready for the 4 year old curriculum. I don't want to set him up for failure, I just don't know what the right thing to do is. Do you (I) just go along with it, or are there certain questions I should ask to confirm that it's the best decision? I feel terrible for even thinking this, but isn't giving him the extra support in this program supposed to avoid holding him back? Or are we not doing enough? Or is he that far behind? What should 3 year old preschoolers know/do that he doesn't? Can we do things at home during the summer to help his progress? Is it okay to ask them these questions at the annual meeting? Is it normal for summer birthday kids to wait an extra year to be in school?
Of course, my older daughters (8 and 9) had already planned what grades they'll all be in (DD9 would be in 5th grade, DD8 would be in 4th grade when the DS3 would be in kindergarten) as they get older. If this is the best decision for him, I want to explain this in a way that they would understand and wouldn't turn this on him later (not that older siblings EVER do that).
Any thoughts? Any other information that would be helpful to know?
Maegan
We have a little guy who will be 4 years old at the end of June. He stays home with my DH during the day and is with me and the girls in the evening. Because he didn't have many social opportunities, we enrolled him in 3 year old preschool and back in November, they had identified a speech delay (he was about a year behind in speech when we started) and a cognitive developmental delay (i.e., he has trouble remembering multi-step directions). He goes to preschool Tuesday and Thursday from 9:00 - 11:30 and since identifying the speech delay, they have him in a Speech Booster class on Mondays from 9:00 - 11:30.
We have his annual review meeting next week. We got a call a month ago from his case manager for us to give thought to holding our little guy back and have him repeat 3 year old preschool next year.
His case manager (that is with him in class on Tuesdays and Thursdays) felt that the 4 year old preschool curriculum was very academic and she didn't think he would be able to keep up. She also indicated that he gets very frustrated when people don't understand him. While he has progressed leaps and bounds since they started him in the speech booster class, I think that it may not be enough to get him ready for the 4 year old curriculum. I don't want to set him up for failure, I just don't know what the right thing to do is. Do you (I) just go along with it, or are there certain questions I should ask to confirm that it's the best decision? I feel terrible for even thinking this, but isn't giving him the extra support in this program supposed to avoid holding him back? Or are we not doing enough? Or is he that far behind? What should 3 year old preschoolers know/do that he doesn't? Can we do things at home during the summer to help his progress? Is it okay to ask them these questions at the annual meeting? Is it normal for summer birthday kids to wait an extra year to be in school?
Of course, my older daughters (8 and 9) had already planned what grades they'll all be in (DD9 would be in 5th grade, DD8 would be in 4th grade when the DS3 would be in kindergarten) as they get older. If this is the best decision for him, I want to explain this in a way that they would understand and wouldn't turn this on him later (not that older siblings EVER do that).
Any thoughts? Any other information that would be helpful to know?
Maegan








I think you need to trust them. I don't think your son will think twice about repeating 3 year old preschool. I used to teach k and I have 2 boys - one with a Sept. birthday and one with an Aug. birthday. Our cutoff date is Sept. 1 but it might as well be June 1. Nobody around here sends their summer birthay kids on. My youngest is in pre-k now (what you are calling the 4 year old class) and it is so different from his 3 year old class. He can write all of his letters and numbers, he is starting to read, he is grasping basic math concepts, he is becoming a little student!
